Selena Gomez Dodges Justin Bieber with David Letterman

Selena Gomez appeared on The Late Show with David Letterman on Wednesday, and the clip from Popstar Online shows that not even he can break through that invisible cone of silence.

Letterman himself points out, “this isn’t my first rodeo,” and his comical light-handed manner has occasionally drawn out information where more serious tactics failed. Unfortunately, it just isn’t happening this time, as Letterman tries every comedic angle he can think of to get Selena to admit she either is or isn’t dating Justin Bieber, although he does get a surprised laugh and a blush from her when he makes a comment about Justin being her paperboy.

We’ve seen Selena and Justin check out No Strings Attached and even look like an actual dating couple, but the couple’s record of mystery remains intact as one more person fails to get a solid answer.

Check out the clip below to see David try his best to get to the truth, only to run into a brick wall every time.